Logo

ARCO's Abolitionists - A Vegan Forum

Vegans exploring the abolitionist approach to Animal Rights

Follow ARCO's Abolitionists on Twitter Become a fan of ARCO's Abolitionists on Facebook

Wiki for Abolitionism & Animal Rights

Constructive animal rights debate; visible to all users and guests.
All abolitionists may post here.

Wiki for Abolitionism & Animal Rights

Postby panthera » Tue Sep 25, 2007 9:41 pm

Wouldn't this be a great idea for an abolitionist to take on? There is, of course, an entry for "Animal Rights," and it actually mentions abolitionism.

Wikipedia on Animal Rights

Abolitionist view

Gary Francione's work (Introduction to Animal Rights, et.al.) is based on the premise that if non-human animals are considered to be property then any rights that they may be granted would be directly undermined by that property status. He points out that a call to equally consider the interests of your property against your own interests is absurd. Without the basic right not to be treated as the property of humans, non-human animals have no rights whatsoever, he says. Francione posits that sentience is the only valid determinant for moral standing, unlike Regan who sees qualitative degrees in the subjective experiences of his "subjects-of-a-life" based upon a loose determination of who falls within that category. Francione claims that there is no actual animal-rights movement in the United States, but only an animal-welfarist movement. In line with his philosophical position and his work in animal-rights law for the Animal Rights Law Project[37] at Rutgers University, he points out that any effort that does not advocate the abolition of the property status of animals is misguided, in that it inevitably results in the institutionalization of animal exploitation. It is logically inconsistent and doomed never to achieve its stated goal of improving the condition of animals, he argues. Francione holds that a society which regards dogs and cats as family members yet kills cows, chickens, and pigs for food exhibits what he calls "moral schizophrenia."

37 ^ Animal Rights: The Abolitionist Approach. Retrieved on 2007-04-02.


(did one of you write this entry?)

We could always add to that, however, in the main article. Insert the abolitionist take on everything, so people become aware that there is a challenge to the status quo.

There is no mention of AAR in the "abolitionism" wiki. Anyone?
:idea:
panthera
Site Admin
 
Posts: 789
Joined: Thu Sep 20, 2007 9:59 pm

Return to Animal Rights Talk



 


  • Related topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post
cron